posted on January 4, 2021 by Lindsey Frydman

What’s Your Genre?

My agent once told me it takes five books for readers to associate your name with your genre. That’s excellent, I thought. Until I took a wide look at the stories I’ve written and the ones I plan to write and quickly realized my books don’t fit into one – or even two – neatly described genres. (They’re not even all young adult novels, though I gravitate toward YA most often.) As an author, it’s obviously essential to have a platform. So what’s a writer to do? For me, I wanted to pin down the common elements within my stories. I always write romance. Always. That label is easy enough, but it’s not the only label that matters, and it doesn’t fully describe what you’ll find in my stories.

If you Google my latest release, To Whatever End, you’ll find it clearly and unanimously labeled three things: a YA novel, a romance, and a fantasy. The first two are obviously true, but the third? Well, of course it is a fantasy. It’s about a girl who’s cursed with seeing the end to all her relationships; it would be unfair to label it contemporary romance and call it a day. But is it truly a fantasy? Yes. And no.

When I set out to write this story, in my head, I labeled it magical realism. For me, the magic didn’t need to make sense. The characters didn’t need to question why it exists, they only needed to react to it. With magical realism, everything out of the ordinary just is, whereas most fantasies systematically lay out how everything works. There are rules, and an order to things. (Vampires either sparkle in the sunlight or they don’t, right?)

A quick Google search defines magical realism like this: a narrative genre characterized by its use of fantastic or mythic elements in otherwise realistic fiction. According to that definition, a story about a girl with a spectacularly crappy curse is magical realism just as much as it is fantasy. But the lines between magical realism and fantasy are blurry, and as a writer, it’s a hard line to walk.

Aside from the ever-present romance element, I’m a huge fan of “everyday magic”. Sometimes that magic takes the form of futuristic science (sexy cyborgs, anyone?), while other times it becomes a magical door leading to another world. Another phrase I attached to my author platform/tagline was “rule-breaking heroes”, which is simply characters not doing what they’re told – and having good reason to do so.

Steven King makes us think horror, Nora Roberts makes us think romance, and James Patterson makes us think thriller. What do I hope readers will think of when they hear my name years from now? In the end, it only matters that I tell an interesting romance. Everything else is fair game. So even though my debut is contemporary, my latest release is fantasy, and my third book is science fiction, they all share a few common threads. Romance. Rule-breaking heroes. And everyday magic.

Yes, the labels and genres are necessary for many reasons, but books (much like people) are so much more than the categories we place them in.

What element is most important to you when it comes to reading and writing? Is it romance, a fantasy world unlike our own, or a good thrill? Or is it something else entirely? Let me know! A random commenter will win a $10 Amazon gift card.

Lindsey Frydman

Lindsey Frydman

Lindsey writes about heart-stopping romance, rule-breaking heroes, and everyday magic. She lives in Ohio (where the weather is never quite right). Her BFA in Photography and Graphic Design has granted her a wide assortment of creative knowledge that serves mostly as inspiration. When she's not crafting stories, you'll likely find her spendingwaaaytoo much time on Pinterest, gaming, or performing in a burlesque show---because she enjoys giving her introversion a worthy adversary. (Plus, it's the closest to Broadway she'll ever get.)

11 thoughts on “What’s Your Genre?”

  1. bn100 says:

    interesting characters

    1. Always important! <3

  2. Angela Ituarte says:

    Thrillers with a touch of romance.

  3. Sherry Haut says:

    Science fiction romance

    1. <3 Jennifer L. Armentrout and Jus Accardo are a couple of my favorites for that genre!

      1. You won! Please email me at so I can send you your giftcard!

  4. SusanM Montford says:

    What elements are mystery thrillers with a touch of erotica, romance suspense and cozy murders with an adult swag. My characters are characters.

    1. These elements remind me of J.D. Robb’s In Death series!

  5. GB says:

    I am, at heart, a romance reader. That is regardless of whether the story is also a suspense, fantasy, paranormal, sci fi, historical, or contemporary. So for me, the relationships and characters need to move me. The vicarious fall into love is a wonderful thing.

    1. Vicarious love IS a wonderful thing! <3

  6. AuntySuzany says:

    Thrills with romance and time travel! Thank you for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest from our Blog


If you know me you probably know by now that I write psychic romantic suspense under three different names:  Jayne Ann Krentz for contemporaries, Amanda Quick for historicals and Jayne Castle for my futuristic stories. Things were going swell until I realized the horrifying truth.  The dust bunnies had taken control of my Jayne Castle… Read More

Read More